Are thicker or thinner guitar necks better for beginners? It’s a question that’s been asked time and time again, and it’s one that doesn’t have a straightforward answer. In this post, we’ll explore the pros and cons of thicker and thinner guitar necks and help you decide which is better for you as a beginner.
First, let’s define what we mean by “thicker” and “thinner” necks. Guitar neck thickness is typically measured at the 1st and 12th frets. Neck thickness can vary based on the guitar’s make and model, but generally speaking, a thickness of 0.85 inches or more is considered “thick,” while a thickness of 0.80 inches or less is considered “thin.”
Thicker Guitar Necks
One of the biggest advantages of thicker guitar necks is the added support they provide for your fingers. When you’re playing chords or barre chords, having a thicker neck can make it easier to press down on the strings without straining your hand. This can be especially helpful for beginners who haven’t yet developed the finger strength needed for playing for long periods of time.
Another benefit of a thicker neck is that it can facilitate better hand positioning. Because the neck is wider, your fingers have more space to navigate between each other, which can help prevent finger cramping or discomfort. Additionally, thicker necks are often associated with guitars that have wider string spacing, which can be helpful for players with larger hands or longer fingers.
However, thicker necks also have some downsides. For one, they can be more challenging to play for players with smaller hands. If your fingers are short or your hand is on the smaller side, you may struggle to comfortably reach around the neck to play certain chords and scales.
Another downside to thicker necks is that they can be more difficult to play for players who prefer to play with their thumb over the top of the neck. This technique is often used in blues and rock guitar playing, and a thicker neck can make it harder to grip the neck in this way.
Thinner Guitar Necks
Thinner necks, on the other hand, offer some distinct benefits of their own. Because they’re narrower and flatter, they can be easier to grip for players with smaller hands. This can be especially helpful for younger or female players who may struggle with thicker necks.
Thinner necks are also often associated with guitars that have a more modern feel. If you’re interested in playing music that leans towards rock, metal, or other modern genres, a thinner neck may be more suitable for you. This is because they offer greater speed and flexibility when playing complex lead lines, and they allow for greater control when performing fast trills or vibrato techniques.
However, thin necks also have their own set of drawbacks. For one, they don’t provide as much support for your fingers as thicker necks. This can make it more challenging to play chords or barre chords for extended periods of time, especially if you’re still developing your finger strength.
Another downside to thin necks is that they can be harder to navigate for players with larger hands. If your fingers are particularly bulky, you may struggle to comfortably move around the neck and avoid accidentally muting adjacent strings.
So, Which is Better?
At the end of the day, there’s no definitive answer to whether a thicker or thinner neck is better for beginners. It really all depends on your personal preferences and playing style. Some players may prefer the added support and improved hand positioning of a thicker neck, while others may appreciate the sleekness and speed of a thinner neck.
If you’re still unsure which type of neck is right for you, it may be worth visiting a music store and trying out a few different guitars with varying neck sizes. This will allow you to get a feel for what you find most comfortable and enjoyable to play.
One last thing to consider when choosing a guitar neck is the shape of the neck profile. This refers to the curvature of the back of the neck and can also impact your playing experience. Generally speaking, there are three main types of neck profiles: C-shaped, V-shaped, and U-shaped.
C-shaped necks have a gentle curve and are often considered the most comfortable and versatile for players of all levels. They’re a good choice if you’re not sure which profile will suit you best.
V-shaped necks have a more angular design, with a pronounced ridge down the center of the back. This can be helpful for players who like to “dig in” to their playing, but it can be uncomfortable for some.
U-shaped necks have a more rounded design that can provide extra support for your hand and a secure grip. However, this profile can feel bulky and restrictive for players who prefer a more streamlined feel.
Conclusion
In the end, whether a thicker or thinner guitar neck is better for you as a beginner depends on a number of factors. Consider your hand size, playing style, and the types of music you’re interested in learning. Try out a few different neck profiles to get a feel for what works best for you.
Remember, the most important thing is to choose a guitar that feels comfortable and inspires you to play. Whether you opt for a thicker or thinner neck, your passion for the instrument should remain your driving force, helping you to develop your skills and enjoy your playing experience.
Image Credit: Pexels